• CerebralHawks@lemmy.dbzer0.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    9 hours ago

    The title implies that the laptops will tie into the Galaxy ecosystem and may/will lock out Pixel users and users of other OEMs.

    Android OEMs have always had an ecosystem problem that Apple doesn’t. Apple can lock everyone else out because no one else makes iPhones. With Android OEMs though, every single one of them benefits from the churn. Just like a disgruntled Samsung user going to Pixel helps everyone, so does a Pixel user going to Samsung. In both cases, Android wins and both companies benefit, albeit indirectly. It’s only considered to be a loss when one of them goes to Apple.

    That’s actually what happened to me. My HTC One M8 shit the bed, and I was looking at Galaxy S7/Edge, HTC 10, LG G5, and Motorola Droid Turbo 2. All shitty choices. Wife picked the Droid Turbo 2 and regretted it (though on paper it was a beast). I reluctantly went with the iPhone 6s. At the time, Android loyalists would say “you shoulda went with the S7” but looking back, you’d have to find a pretty dumb Android fanboy to actually say I made the wrong call. One of the best iPhones vs a really shitty year to need a new Android phone. To compare, while HTC and LG pretty much always sucked (minus a couple outliers), and Motorola’s best days were long behind them, the Galaxy S8 and Pixel 1 were amazing contenders, but one was ~4 months out and the other was almost a year out. And not even announced.

    Android needs some kind of unifying ecosystem that, just like Android (AOSP) itself, OEMs can build upon with their forks, but not take away from. Any Android ecosystem part that rejects any other should be shunned by the community, while anything that includes Apple stuff (like the new open AirDrop the EU forced Apple to adopt) should be promoted. Because if Android is open to Apple, it doesn’t matter if Apple isn’t open to Android (though, it kind of is now, with Apple Music and Apple TV), because you want to get people into the ecosystem you’re in, not keep them out.

    Disclosure of bias: I use an iPhone 16 Pro Max as my main device, and a Galaxy S10 as a music archive. It’s WiFi only — and I prefer browsing and typing on it to the iPhone. My computers are Macs, and my wife still uses Android (Galaxy S22). I like the Mac. I like the iPhone because it’s boring. I also like Android, and I can tell you why both are better at what they’re better at. My bias is toward tech that works for me.

    • Onomatopoeia@lemmy.cafe
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      6 hours ago

      I used to use iPhone only for work phones, because if I can’t really do anything with my phone, may as well “just work”.

      That was years ago. Today you can’t give me an iPhone. It’s so constraining, and Android is just as stable today (if you don’t muck with it like I do my personal phone).

      • xylol@leminal.space
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        5 hours ago

        Yeah the best part about android is you can just ignore the ecosystem. Load a different launcher like kiss and make everything text and search based and it becomes so different and simpler to use. Even better if you self host you can use nextcloud and immich then Plex and jellyfin. It just sucks google is trying to lock all that out of the stock os